Do you teach physics or physical science? Would you like to be part of a teacher-led Physics Study Group? We are proposing to establish one. We are practitioners of a curriculum and pedagogy known as Modeling Instruction, developed collaboratively by university and high school physics educators over the past 20 years.
What is Modeling Instruction? Robert Karplus came up with the idea of modeling in 1969, and it has been developed into a comprehensive approach by Hestenes and many others. Examples of scientific models are the sphere model for the Earth and the particle model for the Solar System. Other types of models are analog models, in which features of one system are used to understand a second system, and mathematical models, in which two (or more) quantities are related together by means of an equation, a graph, a table of numbers or a computer program.
Modeling Instruction, in brief, focuses on developing carefully-selected scientific models through student experiments and structured questioning and discussion. Modelers, beginning with Karplus, have done extensive research on the most common student misconceptions arising in the course of model development. Modeling teachers draw upon a variety of powerful strategies to help students develop and test their own models, thus working through the key misconceptions and learning how to apply the models successfully in problem solving.
Links about Modeling Instruction:
http://modeling.asu.edu/modeling/Mod_Instr-effective.htm
http://modeling.asu.edu/SuccessStories_MI.htm
Proposed activities: We are proposing that The NYC Physics Modeling Group focus on the following types of activities.
- Professional Development that focuses on pedagogy, led by teachers actually using it
- Curriculum which is not textbook-specific and is implemented by all levels of physics teachers, from Physics First to Regents Physics to Advanced Placement Physics
- Ongoing conversation with peer teachers on how to incorporate and implement inquiry teaching into the physics classroom and laboratory settings
- A sustainable cohort of other New York City area Physics teachers open to discuss and support each other on implementing and adapting curriculum to their own classroom realities
If you’re interested, please respond to the survey at
If you supply your name and email in the survey, we will be in touch with you shortly. We hope to schedule an initial organization meeting and workshop sometime before June.
Fernand Brunschwig, Chairman, NYAS Steering Committee, Science Education Initiative (Empire State College and Columbia University Teachers College)
Nathan Finney, Columbia Secondary School for Math, Science, & Engineering (CSS-MSE)
Seth Guinals-Kupperman, High School for Math, Science and Engineering at City College (HSMSE)
Mark Schober, Columbia Secondary School for Math, Science, & Engineering (CSS-MSE)
Andrew Stillman, Program Officer for Digital Instruction, New Visions for Public Schools






[...] with Fernand Brunschwig, Seth Guiñals-Kupperman, Nate Finney, and Andrew Stillman, we formed the Physics Teachers of New York City and have a full slate of monthly workshops for the upcoming school [...]
[...] I’ll be attending EdCamp NYC as part of the NYC Physics Teachers group. I’ll be leading a session on Standards-Based Grading along with fellow physics modelers and [...]